Nitish Tiwari’s Ramayan is a Sincere
Effort That Ultimately Falls Short
Disclaimer: Like any seasoned Telugu
cinephile from the 1960s, 70s, and 80s, approaching this film without a degree
of inherent bias is nearly impossible. My perspective is inevitably shaped by
the towering legacy of the legendary N.T. Rama Rao (NTR). Having immortalised iconic mythological figures—from Lord Rama and Krishna to formidable
antagonists like Ravana and Duryodhana—NTR remains the definitive benchmark for
the genre. For an audience raised on his commanding screen presence,
contemporary actors portraying these roles naturally pale in comparison.
Evaluating Ranbir Kapoor and Yash against that gold standard feels akin to
critiquing Shabbir Kumar’s vocals after decades of listening to Mohammed Rafi.
However, setting nostalgia aside, I have endeavoured to assess the film as
objectively as possible.
Riding a wave of intense pre-release hype over its record-breaking
budget and unprecedented scale, Ramayana: Part One debuted globally to a
thunderous response, delivering on the filmmakers' ambitious vision.
Casting & Acting
In mythological and historical cinema,
casting is half the battle—getting the physicality and aura of iconic figures
right is critical to winning over the audience. Unfortunately, Ramayana
stumbles right out of the gate in this department.
When director Nitesh Tiwari announced Ranbir
Kapoor as Lord Ram and Sai Pallavi as Sita, it immediately felt like a
high-stakes gamble. To be fair to Tiwari, looking at the current crop of
top-tier Bollywood leading men, options are undeniably scarce; virtually any
contemporary star cast in the titular role might have yielded similarly mixed
results as Kapoor.
However, the casting of Sai Pallavi as Sita
proves to be a self-inflicted wound. While there is no denying her acting
prowess, phenomenal dancing skills, or her spotless off-screen image—likely the
very factors that secured her the part—her on-screen portrayal falls flat. She
lacks the regal poise and ethereal grace required to embody a royal princess
and a revered goddess. Whether in the opulent palace sequences or during the
austere Vanavas (exile) portions, her screen presence feels far too
ordinary, resulting in a thoroughly underwhelming performance.
Audiences who have grown up watching
actresses like Jamuna, Jayalalithaa, Jaya Prada, and television’s Dipika
Chikhlia effortlessly personify the timeless dignity and charm of Sita will
find this rendition starkly lacking.
While Ranbir Kapoor has repeatedly proven his
versatility as a performer—most notably in films like Sanju and Animal—his
portrayal of Lord Rama falls short of the mark. Stepping into the shoes of a
revered mythological figure demands a distinct aura, commanding dialogue
delivery, and classical poise that diverge sharply from the naturalistic acting
required in contemporary dramas or action thrillers. Kapoor appears constrained
by these stylistic boundaries, often relying on a blank, understated expression
that struggles to convey the divine gravitas of the character.
Conversely, Yash delivers a towering
performance as Ravana, effortlessly commanding the screen and outshining the
rest of the ensemble, Kapoor included. Despite giving Kapoor significantly more
screen time, the filmmakers cannot prevent Yash’s sheer screen presence, body
language, and imposing wardrobe from dominating the narrative. However,
accusations that the film deliberately glorifies the antagonist miss crucial
cinematic and theatrical context. Indian cinema has a rich tradition of
spotlighting Ravana’s complexity; N.T. Rama Rao famously anchored Bhookailas
(1958) and Seetharama Kalyanam (1961) in the role, treating Rama’s
presence in the latter as a virtual cameo. Similarly, in the acclaimed stage
production Humare Ram, Ashutosh Rana dominates as the Demon King, yet
Rahul Bhuchar holds his own as Rama through impeccable diction and
physicality—qualities that would have made Bhuchar an ideal cinematic Rama,
save for the commercial pull of a mainstream star like Kapoor.
As for the supporting cast, the tonal
inconsistency persists. Lakshmana is reduced to clumsy comic relief, with the
actor frequently breaking the period illusion and appearing detached from the
mythological setting. Amid these uneven performances, Rakul Preet Singh stands
out as a bright spot, delivering a convincing and well-calibrated turn as
Shurpanakha.
A Bloated Runtime and Flawed Writing: Why This Adaptation of the Ramayana Falters
Despite a sprawling runtime of three hours
and fifteen minutes, the film’s biggest casualties are its story and
screenplay. Rather than offering a comprehensive retelling of the Ramayana,
the narrative leaves out several pivotal chapters. Burdened by loose pacing,
the film struggles to maintain momentum, resulting in a viewing experience that
works only in sporadic patches.
Equally jarring is the quality of the
dialogue. While filmmakers often adapt language to suit contemporary audiences,
a mythological epic demands a certain linguistic gravitas and period
authenticity. Here, the writing takes far too many liberties. The casual use of
colloquialisms like "tum" and "tu" strikes a
discordant note, pointing to a glaring lack of research on the part of the
director and the dialogue-writing team.
This disregard for traditional nuance is most
evident in the handling of the Surpanakha episode—a critical catalyst in the
epic's narrative. Across established versions of the Ramayana, Lakshmana
severs both Surpanakha’s nose and ears. Despite the sophistication of modern
prosthetics and makeup, the film settles for a minor, superficial nick on her
nose that looks as though it would heal in a matter of days. More importantly,
the screenplay completely bypasses her underlying motivation: manipulating
Ravana into war to avenge her husband's death at his hands. One need only look
at the stage production Hamare Ram, where a powerhouse performance in
the same role drew thunderous applause, to see what this cinematic adaptation
misses.
Finally, while the director has stated that
the film draws from multiple literary versions of the epic, certain creative
liberties remain baffling—most notably the unexplained portrayal of Sita as a
sword-wielding warrior, a depiction absent from traditional texts. Ultimately,
weak writing and questionable creative choices undermine what could have been a
landmark retelling.
Visual Effects, CGI, and Production Design: A
Question of Scale Versus Execution
However, while the visual effects are
passable, they fall short of the extraordinary standard promised by a boasted
budget exceeding ₹2,000 crore. By
comparison, recent films like Hanu-Man and Mirai—made on budgets
under ₹125 crore—along
with the animated feature Narasimha, delivered far more compelling
visual spectacles. It raises a pertinent question as to where the massive ₹2,000 crore outlay was actually utilized. Key sequences,
such as the Jatayu episode, feel merely adequate, while the rendering of
demonic characters, including Kumbhakarna, appears surprisingly rudimentary.
Equally underwhelming is the production
design and art direction. Mythological epics thrive on grand architectural
scale and opulent palaces, yet the sets here fail to leave a lasting
impression. More than a decade after its release, Baahubali remains the
gold standard for world-building, having leased hundreds of acres at Ramoji
Film City to construct monumental, tactile sets that completely eclipsed what
is seen here.
The costume and jewellery departments also
struggle to deliver regal authenticity. As a prince, Lord Ram’s styling feels
remarkably understated, reduced to a simple, thin chain around his neck. One
wonders if this minimalist approach was a deliberate choice to accommodate
Ranbir Kapoor, who—much like several of his Bollywood contemporaries—may not
naturally carry the weight of heavy traditional attire and ornate jewellery.
Conversely, Yash commands the screen, wearing his elaborate costumes, heavy
jewellery, and overall look with striking conviction
Music: Mythological films traditionally rely on a
rich tapestry of songs, slokas, and Padyams to drive the
narrative forward. However, Ramayan largely abandons this convention,
featuring barely two tracks—including a surprising Sufi-style number. While the
stellar background score helps compensate for the sparse soundtrack, the film
misses the traditional musical gravitas the genre demands. Veteran composers
like Ilaiyaraaja or Academy Award-winner M.M. Keeravani might have brought a
deeper cultural resonance and a more fitting musical palette to an epic of this
scale.
The Verdict : Walking out of the theatre, one is
left with an overwhelming sense of a missed opportunity. Backed by a
staggering, reported budget of ₹2,000 crore—resources
substantial enough to secure top-tier global talent both in front of and behind
the camera—the final product falls conspicuously short
of its potential. Creative liberties and narrative distortions aside, the film
may still resonate with Gen Z viewers, particularly among Hindi-speaking
audiences who have experienced a decades-long drought of mainstream
mythological cinema. Moving forward, the onus is on the director and his
creative team to course-correct and address these missteps in the upcoming
sequel. Notably, the casting of Sunny
Doel as Lord Hanuman appears to be a risky gamble, leaving audiences bracing
for whatever unconventional choices the makers have in store next.
S. Prabhakar



.jpeg)
.jpeg)



.jpeg)

.jpeg)





.jpeg)


.jpeg)


.jpeg)
.jpeg)


